Oh my, what a week we have coming in English Comp, the dreaded peer reviews! This is my second time of taking English 1 and 2 (took years ago and credits never transferred) so I am very comfortable with having people read my papers and critique them. However, I was very slow in getting started on this assignment and feel like even though this is a rough draft it is not polished enough and ready to be read. I hate when a paper simply supplies information for a grade, if you are going to put forth effort and put your name on something you might as well do your best. I want to make my essay an entertaining and enjoyable experience for those who read it, be successful in putting research into written form, and produce a grade that reflects my efforts and abilities.
Peer reviews are often not as critical as people might think. I think we all know what it’s like to be in the other’s shoes and are very sympathetic in our critiquing. Many times I have seen essays that were way off subject or poorly written receive rave reviews from friends and class mates. I find this unfair and demeaning to the individual who wrote the paper as the final grade is going to tell all and if peers had just been honest the paper may have stood a chance of receiving a better grade. You can be honest when reviewing another’s writing; it is all in how you say something not necessarily in what you say. For anyone reading this, if you happen to read my essay, PLEASE be brutally honest, I want to learn from my mistakes.